For the 2nd time this week a circuit court of appeals affirms summary judgment on claims brought by former HR employees who seemed to be causing rather than resolving employment issues. In Friday's decision Luckie v. Ameritech Corp. (7th Cir. 11/19/04) [pdf], Ms. Luckie, an organizational development specialist was described as having a "toxic effect" on the department. Ultimately, put on a performance improvement plan, she didn't improve and was terminated. She sued alleging racial harassment and retaliation. On racial harassment, the Court noted it was atypical, since it did not involve "racial slurs, epithets, or other overtly racial behavior" but rather referred to three specific incidents, a comment that a minority employee of the department was a "dunce", an email sent by one of her subordinates complaining about her management and a comment by her supervisor that she wanted to change "the complexion" of the department. The court found only the last could have any conceivable relationship to race, and given that it was made in the context of a re-organization of the department, was not racial. In any event, the actions were not severe and pervasive.
Her retaliation claim fared no better as she could not show any direct evidence that her superior actually knew of her protected activity. Nor could she meet the prima facie case under the indirect method since she could not show she was satisfactorily performing her job.
As a last point, the court dealt with a fundamental hearsay issue. The plaintiff objected to evidence of comments (including the "toxic effect" on the department) made by others that were considered by the manager in making the decision. The objection -- hearsay; the answer, overruled. It is not hearsay because it is not offered for the truth of the matter asserted. Nothing more but restating the basic definition of hearsay, but music to the ears of any management side lawyer who has been thwarted in trying to get what is often 'critical' evidence admitted because the judge 'forgot' that all out of court statements are not hearsay.
Earlier in the week, the 5th Circuit upheld a summary judgment against a former HR employee, Marilyn Haley who alleged that she had been constructively discharged following her return from a stress induced FMLA leave. The stress arose after an employee survey raised concerns and criticisms about the HR department, including Haley. The Court found her evidence that she was micromanaged and that her position had changed insufficient to raise a fact issue as to whether she was constructively discharged. Haley v. Alliance Compressor LLC (5th Cir. 11/18/04) [pdf]. Absent discharge, she had no claim.
Although employers are often justifiably concerned when HR employees sue, perhaps attributable to the "they know where the bodies are buried" syndrome, as this week's result show, all is not always lost when they sue.
Investing for Beginners
Natural Protein Supplements
Education Service Network
Web Design Trends
Small Business Loans
luxury travel and tourism
Online Personal loan
Auto Part Repair
Instant Payday Loans Information
Business Web Design Services
Education Psychology Therapy
Home Business Ideas
Natural Skin Care
Small Business Loans
Business Loans and Finance
Information About Technology Web Design
Drug Rehab Center
Business Plan Consulting
Small business web design
Information Of Software And Technology
Drug Abuse (Mechanism of Drug Abuse and Dependence)
Skin Care and Beauty
Breast Cancer Care and Treatment
Cosmetic Dermatology and Aesthetic Surgery
Destination Vacation Travel
Cancer Antioxidant And Vitamins
Personal Financial Management
Healthy Calories and Weight loss
Small business web design
Lawyer and Legal Information
Healthy Men
lawyer education
Real Estate Property And Contraction
Investing for Beginners
Natural Protein Supplements
Education Service Network
Web Design Trends
Small Business Loans
luxury travel and tourism
Online Personal loan
Auto Part Repair
Instant Payday Loans Information
Business Web Design Services
Education Psychology Therapy
Home Business Ideas
Natural Skin Care
Small Business Loans
Business Loans and Finance
Information About Technology Web Design
Drug Rehab Center
Business Plan Consulting
Small business web design
Information Of Software And Technology
Drug Abuse (Mechanism of Drug Abuse and Dependence)
Skin Care and Beauty
Breast Cancer Care and Treatment
Cosmetic Dermatology and Aesthetic Surgery
Destination Vacation Travel
Cancer Antioxidant And Vitamins
Personal Financial Management
Healthy Calories and Weight loss
Small business web design
Lawyer and Legal Information
Healthy Men
lawyer education
Real Estate Property And Contraction
Online Payday Cash Loans
Online Music Stores
Programming and Computer Software
Healthy Diet
Insurance For Property Protection
Small Business Consulting
Credit And Loan Advice
University College Online
Payday Loan Consulting
Business Corporate Entertainment
Gadgets And Electronics
Education for health
Personal Loans College Students
Online Casino Gambling
Interior Home Design and Decorating
Health Education Centers
Home Design Plans
Finance Auto Sales
Health effects of drug abuse
Drugs And Supplement
Unsecured Personal Loans Online
Health Care Insurance
Popular Posts
-
This afternoon two juries in two separate London Crown Courts have delivered their verdicts in cases which have involved Defendants that hav...
-
A balmy 11 degrees but with a fairly stiff south-westerly wind and with the skies changing from bright to threatening as the race progressed...
-
In the blowing ambiance of the law, to accurate any abridgement of confidence, vulnerability or self-doubt has commonly been admired as...
-
There has been considerable media interest in the reaction of the Criminal Justice System to the summer rioting that broke out in many major...
-
The current civil litigation surrounding whether the Ka-Nefer-Nefer mummy mask is contraband is worth following given the current legal argu...
-
Marie Vesco was a young (19 year old) French woman with high ideals, priniciples and integrity. She was an environmentalist and so chose to...
-
A first for me, I turned up on Saturday afternoon to the first race of the Imperial Winter Series as a spectator and to show a bit of suppor...
-
The BeyondChron, a San Francisco alternative newspaper has an interesting article by Randy Shaw , The Obama/Progressive Agenda: A Progress R...
-
An employee alleged his discharge was because of his epilepsy and because the employer perceived he had a limiting disability, his emotional...
-
We have now come to the end of a terrific summer of cycling (well almost, I hope to catch some of the Tour of Britain this Sunday). The day...
Blogroll
azplanningforwildlife.com
m2tvchannel.com
bapedaldaprovjambi.com
kreis-dl.net
news-1212.com
landratsamt-doebeln.net
landkreis-doebeln.net
canadiangoldreserves.net
chicagohearse.com
tattooremovalessex.com
braziltrade-uae.com
333asia.com
calliemacdesigns.com
gemdoc.net
simplefoodjuiceplus.com
postabortionstresssyndrome.com
descendingpath.com
casadopinhole.net
myspeechandlanguage.net
sezambook.com
rerecognition.info
bebetsy.info
carsoncitybraces.info
summitcardiology.info
sanfojiangsi.info
trailheadgeararchery.info
immigrationconnect.info
nhhomeless.info
tundradialogues.info
ibexretail.com
kreis-dl.com
agiles-eam.com
bestbcgolfcourse.com
niittyneito.com
yenikapimevlevihanesi.com
hnr100.com
eplogin.com
richard-wagner-festival.com
landratsamt-doebeln.com
lra-doebeln.com
terrecatalane.com
thesmarterhybrids.com
Political Science,Politics And Religion,Lamp For Home,Internet Media Services,Book Holidays Online,Electric Car Engine,House And Garden Magazine,Fashion Art Music,Allobits Business Finance Solutions,Amelia Island Living,Sectb Business management,Biblepl College And University,Synergysigns Home Furniture,Marketing and Promotion,Meristem Nature,Success Business,Food and Nutrition,New Health Foundation,Real Estate Designer,Chase Auto Loans,Economic and Business Review,Business Insurance Quotes,Gambling Commission,Game and Media Technology,TakingBusinessOpportunities,MedicalCenter,FashionModelling,FashionCelebrity,BusinessMarketing,ComputersandTechnology,SubjectAboutTechnology,Children'sEducation,EconomicsBusinessandFinance,Entertainment,BusinessAccounting,HealthTechnology,AirHealth,BodyHealth,HousingDesigners,ArtsandEntertainment,GamingTournament,ForexEducation,HomeDesignIdea,BeautyClinic
Professional Translation
Streaming Wizard
Alcoholism and Drug
Medical Laboratory
Commerce Business
Educational Kids Play
Space Education
Home Repair Volunteer
Fashion Talent
Health and Safety Executive
Play Web Games
Travel and Surfing
Property and Estate Agents
Technology Group Solutions
Student Service Center
Construction Industry
Media Center Computer
Teny Fashion
Home Remodeling Services
Inspector Network
Car Rentals
Leader Dogs
Rise Health Systems
Business Strategy Consultant
Personal Life Coaching
Company Business Coaching
Entertainment News
Physics and Astronomy
Science and Technology
Cheap Vacation Packages
World Business Academy
Planets Project
Travel and Leisure
Prevent Drug Abuse
Education Certified
Play Kids Games
Legal Defense Fund
Real Estate Strategies
Isolation Globale
Insurance Coverage Law
Rock Hotel and Resorts
Medical Insurance
Healthy Mind and Body
Marjahaan Autokatsastus
Free Sports Authority
Auto Insurance Coverage
Global Technics
Advitium Manufacturing
Professional Core Education
Special Finance Services
Bergen County Contractors
Great Children's Art
Health Supply Company
Social Media Power
Texas House Restaurant
Carbon Consultant
Carbon Expert
Low Carbon
Reset Carbon
Healthcare Commissioning
Virtual Job Tryouts
Ethos Academy (Education)
Intrinsic Schools
Attorney General
Technology Software
Business Plans
Digital Media
High School Resources
Adult Resources
Gamblers Anonymous
Ecuador Real Estate
Software Development
Festival Fashion
Drugs And Alcohol
Food Network Recipes
Journal Human Resources
Games and Technology
Technology Development
Web Resources Express
Payday Loans Bad Credit
Art and Craft
Business and Finance News
Ecological Sciences
Education Resources
Web Design
Music Education
World Resources Institute
Business Health Guide
Personal Life Coaching
Company Business Coaching
Entertainment News
Physics and Astronomy
Science and Technology
Cheap Vacation Packages
World Business Academy
Planets Project
Travel and Leisure
Prevent Drug Abuse
Education Certified
Play Kids Games
Legal Defense Fund
Real Estate Strategies
Isolation Globale
Insurance Coverage Law
Rock Hotel and Resorts
Medical Insurance
Healthy Mind and Body
Marjahaan Autokatsastus
Free Sports Authority
Auto Insurance Coverage
Global Technics
Advitium Manufacturing
Professional Core Education
Special Finance Services
Bergen County Contractors
Great Children's Art
Health Supply Company
Social Media Power
Texas House Restaurant
Carbon Consultant
Carbon Expert
Low Carbon
Reset Carbon
Healthcare Commissioning
Virtual Job Tryouts
Ethos Academy (Education)
Intrinsic Schools
Attorney General
Technology Software
Business Plans
Digital Media
High School Resources
Adult Resources
Gamblers Anonymous
Ecuador Real Estate
Software Development
Festival Fashion
Drugs And Alcohol
Food Network Recipes
Journal Human Resources
Games and Technology
Technology Development
Web Resources Express
Payday Loans Bad Credit
Art and Craft
Business and Finance News
Ecological Sciences
Education Resources
Web Design
Music Education
World Resources Institute
Business Health Guide
Archives
-
▼
2004
(379)
-
▼
November
(36)
- Advertising Campaigns and Workplace Safety - There...
- NLRB Fails Its Own "Smell Test"
- Price of New York Street Food to Rise?
- 6th Circuit Upholds "Contractual" Statute of Limi...
- Bush Board Reverses Clinton Board, This Time on Jo...
- Who's Packing in the Car?
- Good Business by Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi
- Is Arrest For Drug Paraphernalia Reasonable Cause ...
- Qui Tam Action Dismissed, But Whistleblowing Claim...
- All Department Heads Are Not Created Equal
- This Employment Contract Is A "Badly Drafted Agree...
- Sometimes the Settlement Is Only the Beginning
- Morelia Bound
- Turmoil In the HR Department - Management Wins, T...
- Introducing - The Law.com Blogging Network
- MDV - Boeing Hit for $2.5 Million in Age Discrimin...
- Unionizing the Pizza Delivery Guy
- MDV: Lesbian Cop Wins Millions In Harassment Case
- Last Chance Agreement Strictly Interpreted by 5th ...
- Tar Baby - Part II
- The Employee Tar Baby - When You Just Can't Let Go
- Pittsburgh Requirement for Union Agreement Not Pre...
- Think Comp Time Is the Answer? Might Want to Check...
- Ever Wanted to Modify Your Benefits Plan and the M...
- They Are Back! Legislators Begin Prefiling Bills f...
- Construction Labor Law - A New Blog
- A Reminder Once Again - the NLRA Is Applicable in ...
- Burden of Proof On "Direct Threat" Can Be On Employee
- Working Notice - A Potential Problem
- Department of Labor's 2004 FMLA Opinion Letters
- Missing From Action? Unscheduled Absence Hits 5 Ye...
- Next Senate Chair of Health, Education, Labor, and...
- The Basic Form - The Employment Application
- 7th Cir. No Constructive Discharge Just Because of...
- The Change That Didn't Happen - What A Kerry Admi...
- How to Handle Telling the Boss (or Potential Boss)...
-
▼
November
(36)