The Private Sector Implications of Garcetti v. Ceballos

Since I almost never represent public sector employers, I don't pay close attention to those decisions which focus on issues that are unique to government employers. However, anytime the Supreme Court speaks, particularly as we try to discern its course with two new justices, it probably is a good time to pay a little closer attention.

That Garcetti v. Ceballos (S.Ct. 5/30/06) [pdf] might be such a case was hinted at when the Court had it reargued following Justice Alito's confirmation. Today's 5-4 decision is being heralded in some quarters as the first case that clearly would have been decided differently if Justice O'Connor had remained on the bench. Interesting though it is, I will leave that debate to the Supreme Court cognoscenti.

The Court's holding was relatively simple: speech uttered while carrying out one's duties as a governmental employee is not protected by the First Amendment. Justice Kennedy (as the new swing man) went to the heart of the matter:
We hold that when public employees make statements pursuant to their official duties, the employees are not speaking as citizens for First Amendment purposes, and the Constitution does not insulate their communications from employer discipline.
Left open for further refining is exactly when an employee speaks "pursuant to his official duties" and the question of whether academic freedom may be a special, more protected, form of speech.

For the private sector I thought Justice Kennedy's opinion showed both a real world understanding of the work place, and the principle established may carry some weight in two areas that do impact the private sector. With respect to quotes, every employer should like the following:
Ceballos’ proposed contrary rule, adopted by the Court of Appeals, would commit state and federal courts to a new, permanent, and intrusive role, mandating judicial oversight of communications between and among government employees and their superiors in the course of official business. This displacement of managerial discretion by judicial supervision finds no support in our precedents.
And since I am not a big fan of job descriptions, I personally enjoyed the following:
Formal job descriptions often bear little resemblance to the duties an employee actually is expected to perform, and the listing of a given task in an employee’s written job description is neither necessary nor sufficient to demonstrate that conducting the task is within the scope of the employee’s professional duties for First Amendment purposes.
Finally, although not a direct carry over, today's opinion should bolster similar rulings under various whistleblower statutes that employees who make complaints in the course of their regular duties are not in fact whistleblowers, but merely "doing their job." It may also slow what some have seen as the possibility of an emerging constitutional defense for certain conduct in the workplace. See First Amendment Defense in the May 29th National Law Journal.

Blogroll

azplanningforwildlife.com m2tvchannel.com bapedaldaprovjambi.com kreis-dl.net news-1212.com landratsamt-doebeln.net landkreis-doebeln.net canadiangoldreserves.net chicagohearse.com tattooremovalessex.com braziltrade-uae.com 333asia.com calliemacdesigns.com gemdoc.net simplefoodjuiceplus.com postabortionstresssyndrome.com descendingpath.com casadopinhole.net myspeechandlanguage.net sezambook.com rerecognition.info bebetsy.info carsoncitybraces.info summitcardiology.info sanfojiangsi.info trailheadgeararchery.info immigrationconnect.info nhhomeless.info tundradialogues.info ibexretail.com kreis-dl.com agiles-eam.com bestbcgolfcourse.com niittyneito.com yenikapimevlevihanesi.com hnr100.com eplogin.com richard-wagner-festival.com landratsamt-doebeln.com lra-doebeln.com terrecatalane.com thesmarterhybrids.com Political Science,Politics And Religion,Lamp For Home,Internet Media Services,Book Holidays Online,Electric Car Engine,House And Garden Magazine,Fashion Art Music,Allobits Business Finance Solutions,Amelia Island Living,Sectb Business management,Biblepl College And University,Synergysigns Home Furniture,Marketing and Promotion,Meristem Nature,Success Business,Food and Nutrition,New Health Foundation,Real Estate Designer,Chase Auto Loans,Economic and Business Review,Business Insurance Quotes,Gambling Commission,Game and Media Technology,TakingBusinessOpportunities,MedicalCenter,FashionModelling,FashionCelebrity,BusinessMarketing,ComputersandTechnology,SubjectAboutTechnology,Children'sEducation,EconomicsBusinessandFinance,Entertainment,BusinessAccounting,HealthTechnology,AirHealth,BodyHealth,HousingDesigners,ArtsandEntertainment,GamingTournament,ForexEducation,HomeDesignIdea,BeautyClinic Professional Translation Streaming Wizard Alcoholism and Drug Medical Laboratory Commerce Business Educational Kids Play Space Education Home Repair Volunteer Fashion Talent Health and Safety Executive Play Web Games Travel and Surfing Property and Estate Agents Technology Group Solutions Student Service Center Construction Industry Media Center Computer Teny Fashion Home Remodeling Services Inspector Network Car Rentals Leader Dogs Rise Health Systems Business Strategy Consultant
Personal Life Coaching
Company Business Coaching
Entertainment News
Physics and Astronomy
Science and Technology
Cheap Vacation Packages
World Business Academy
Planets Project
Travel and Leisure
Prevent Drug Abuse
Education Certified
Play Kids Games
Legal Defense Fund
Real Estate Strategies
Isolation Globale
Insurance Coverage Law
Rock Hotel and Resorts
Medical Insurance
Healthy Mind and Body
Marjahaan Autokatsastus
Free Sports Authority
Auto Insurance Coverage
Global Technics
Advitium Manufacturing
Professional Core Education
Special Finance Services
Bergen County Contractors
Great Children's Art
Health Supply Company
Social Media Power
Texas House Restaurant
Carbon Consultant
Carbon Expert
Low Carbon
Reset Carbon
Healthcare Commissioning
Virtual Job Tryouts
Ethos Academy (Education)
Intrinsic Schools
Attorney General
Technology Software
Business Plans
Digital Media
High School Resources
Adult Resources
Gamblers Anonymous
Ecuador Real Estate
Software Development
Festival Fashion
Drugs And Alcohol
Food Network Recipes
Journal Human Resources
Games and Technology
Technology Development
Web Resources Express
Payday Loans Bad Credit
Art and Craft
Business and Finance News
Ecological Sciences
Education Resources
Web Design
Music Education
World Resources Institute
Business Health Guide